in

FA Cup Controversy: Barnsley Expelled for Fielding Ineligible Player in First-Round Replay

Barnsley has been disqualified from the FA Cup due to the use of an ineligible player in their first-round replay. This decision was made recently, on November 22, 2023.

Barnsley has been disqualified from the FA Cup because they played a player who was not eligible in their victory against non-league Horsham during the first-round replay.

The team from the seventh division will be facing Sutton United from League Two in the second round.

Last week, the Tykes from League One emerged victorious with a 3-0 win in the replay match. The initial match at Oakwell had ended in a 3-3 draw.

On the club's official website, a statement was released where they expressed their apologies to their fans, players, and staff for a mistake that they deeply regret.

Barnsley have chosen not to disclose the identity of the player involved. However, according to the regulations set by the Football Association, only those players who were eligible to participate in the original FA Cup match are allowed to take

Aiden Marsh, who plays as a forward, had temporarily joined York City in the National League. He participated in the first game on 3 November but was brought back to his original team three days later. Later on, the 20-year-old player began as a starter in the rematch that took place in West Sussex on 14 November.

Barnsley's statement expressed that the mistake made, even though it was not intentional, does not meet the high standards that they have set for themselves as a club. They acknowledged that this is not what their supporters deserve.

"We have already completed a thorough examination within our organization and as a result, implemented measures to prevent any recurrence of such incidents in the future."

Barnsley has the option to challenge the decision, however, the Tykes have stated that they have acknowledged and agreed

As a result of the decision, Horsham, a team in the Isthmian League Premier Division, will have the opportunity to compete in the second round of the FA Cup for only the second time ever.

Kevin Borrett, the chairman of Horsham, expressed his satisfaction for his club's success. He also expressed his sympathy towards Barnsley and acknowledged that their fans would be devastated. He genuinely wished them the best.

Over the weekend, I had several discussions with the Barnsley chair as they were getting ready to respond to the FA charge.

I believe that both clubs have had a great relationship throughout the matches, and the fans have also found common ground on a few matters, resulting in a strong connection between them.

He expressed, "We should not underestimate Sutton. They are a formidable team and part of a higher league. We will approach the game as underdogs, but with a mindset that victory is within our grasp."

"I believe Sutton will approach this game with utmost seriousness and not underestimate its importance."

Bury is the only club that has been expelled from the competition in 2006, specifically at the first-round stage or later. This occurred when Bury, who was a League Two side at the time, played Stephen Turnbull on loan from Hartlepool without the necessary authorization in a second-round replay against Chester, which they won.

Chester was given back its previous status and proceeded to suffer a defeat against Ipswich in a replay that took place during the third round.

In the seasons of 2010-11 and 2012-13, Droylsden and Bradford City were initially disqualified but later reinstated following an appeal process.

It is quite puzzling how this error could have occurred.

It is not uncommon for administrative errors to occur in football, but it remains puzzling as to why they happen in the first place. The fans, especially those who attended the replay in Horsham, as well as some club officials, including the person responsible, understandably feel angry and embarrassed.

However, it is important to acknowledge that Barnsley cooperated with the FA's investigation, took responsibility for their actions, and made a commitment to prevent similar mistakes in the future. There isn't much more they can do in this situation. Fortunately, the entire process has been relatively fast.

Best wishes to Horsham as they face Sutton. It is highly likely that the victorious team will secure a highly desirable match in the third round of the FA Cup, consequently generating criticism for the Reds.

Opinions and thoughts can be shared here. Feel free to participate in the discussion. However

Comments were posted by various users at different times on November 22nd. Sir Ad E Noid, TheBear, rememberscarborough, Allanon, Tom, Debby, Michael, johnyandthecat, Changing Times, Andrejg8923, Name, JP, VoiceOfReason, Baldeeheed, You, 3 Up 3 Down, Monksie, oadbyfox, Keith, Ejvind, something2say, Margaret, NorthandSouth, stan24, Lets Agree To Disagree, John, RandomMan, Owls49, Munksyb, Bat21, Eaststand, Zeppo, and PatrickBWFC were the users who commented or replied. The top stories discussed were the VAR debate, a bizarre goal in a Barnsley match, and the Champions League. Other topics included Lewis Hamilton's self-doubt, new rules banning coaches from weighing gymnasts, and how to follow your Premier League team on the BBC.

Football enthusiasts can catch up on the latest buzz and speculations circulating in the world of football. Stay updated with the most recent

Phil McNulty, our chief football writer, provides analysis and opinions on various football topics.

Ways to become involved in football

Discover the path to becoming involved in football – the globally renowned sport, with numerous clubs and facilities available across the United Kingdom.

On other parts of the BBC, there is a focus on the mysterious death of an intelligent MI6 agent. Explore further into the case of Gareth Williams, who was discovered dead inside a bag in his bathtub in 2010.

The story of William Shakespeare's life and the impact he left behind

How did a young boy from the Midlands manage to achieve such widespread recognition as the most renowned playwright in the English-speaking world?

Do you think you can identify these iconic actresses of the silver screen? Put your knowledge of famous movie queens to the test with this enjoyable quiz

Each detective carries a case that has had a lasting impact on them. In a fresh true crime series, police officers reflect on the particular case that significantly influenced their professional trajectory.

Additionally in the world of sports, there has been a decline in the Chinese Super League, ranging from attempting to acquire Gareth Bale to even selling

McColgan is optimistic about securing a surprise bronze medal in the Olympic 10,000m race.

'Gary, it's not good for you to be in an offside position' – Venables, Lineker and Hughes discuss their time at Barcelona.

The frenzy over Messi is considered one of the greatest movements in American sports.

Lineker believes that Venables is the greatest English coach that has ever been.

The NFL Plays of the Week featured impressive one-handed catches and a spectacular 99-yard touchdown.

"Garnacho's goal was the best I have witnessed in person," exclaims the onlooker, as he scores what is considered

'An exceptional individual and pioneer – Venables' enduring impact at Barcelona'

The positive and uplifting feeling surrounding the Spurs team is not expected to endure indefinitely.

Who qualifies as a valuable player? Garth Crooks' selects his Team of the Week.

Garnacho's remarkable bicycle kick is an extraordinary feat that happens very rarely.

Red Bull's impressive dominance leaves their rivals with an intimidating challenge ahead, comparable to scaling Mount

A vibrant and captivating figure – Terry Venables' obituary

Shaw scores three goals as Manchester City convincingly defeat Tottenham Hotspur.

'It feels amazing to defy the expectations of others and reclaim my position of success.'

In an exciting rematch, Taylor emerges victorious over Cameron

Discover the vast offerings of the BBC

What do you think?

Written by

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings

Achieving Sustainability and Profitability: A Focus on Client-Focused Adviser Firms

The Abolition of UK Lifetime Allowance for Pension Pot: On Track for April 2024